And now for some good news

Nicole Hasham’s story on page three of the Sydney Morning Herald today is a great example of simple, clear reporting: Politics of prejudice as cultural cowboys court xenophobic vote.

It’s about Nick Folkes of the Australian Protectionist Party running in next month’s council elections. She interviewed Folkes, mentioned his previously unsuccessful run (0.6 per cent of the vote in Balmain last year), interviewed Professor Kevin Dunn from the University of Western Sydney (who researches immigration, multiculturalism and racism), and interviewed Peter Wong, founder of the Unity Party and briefly outlined that party’s political history. All that in a 456 word story.

(The funniest bit was finding out that Sergio ‘Say no to burqas mural, aka Muslims aren’t allowed to tell women what to wear but I’m allowed to tell women what to wear’ Redegalli is running for Marrickville Council – one of the most multicultural electorates in the state. Yeah, good luck with that.)

Contrast Hasham’s story with the story placed above it on page three, from Environment Editor Ben Cubby, who’s been pulled up here before for lazy journalism: Cause for optimism on global warming.

It’s 475 words about a report that he doesn’t name so readers can’t easily find it and therefore have to take his word for it that he’s reporting it accurately (I assume it’s The Critical Decade: International Action on Climate Change), with a quote from Opposition climate spokesman Greg Hunt that ranges from clearly wrong (South Korea) to somewhat wrong (the US and Canada) but is left unchecked by Cubby. Like all politicians, Hunt knows that he can pretty much just make shit up and journalists will report it without pointing out that there’s no evidence to support the claims. There’s a general quote from Minister for Climate Change Greg Combet and a general quote from Climate Commissioner Tim Flannery that sound like they’re from the media release that arrived with the report. I’m happy to be wrong about that. If a journalism student submitted this story for an assignment, they’d be lucky to pass.

But back to the good bit. Nice work, Nicole Hasham.

4 responses to “And now for some good news

  1. Interesting too that Cubby’s numbers don’t line up: easy example, “850 million people affected”, including “China & US”. Given that India’s also listed there as having a price, I make that about 2.5-3 billion people… unless he means that only some areas of those countries have those prices (which is the case for China at least, based on Hack on JJJ yesterday). Ultimately though, I have no idea what his point is.

    Agree with you on Hasham’s article.

  2. I got Sergio Redegalli’s flyer for council elections in the post the other day. It smelt a dog whistle in the subtleties of his text and then connected the dots with who he was…in the BIN

Go on, you know you have something to say...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s